By 
Which Decking Material Is Right for Your Home?
With so many decking materials available today, it’s easy to become overwhelmed. Composite or PVC? Trex or TimberTech? Which collection is worth the investment?
At Weatherguard, we can install virtually any major decking brand or collection. However, after designing and building decks throughout Minnesota and western Wisconsin for more than 25 years, we’ve found ourselves recommending four collections more than any others.
Why?
Because they offer the best combination of value, performance, durability, and long-term beauty at each investment level. Rather than overwhelming homeowners with dozens of options, we’ve simplified the decision into four categories.
Composite vs. Advanced PVC: What’s the Difference?
One of the most common questions we hear is, “What’s the difference between composite decking and PVC decking?” While both are low-maintenance alternatives to traditional wood, they’re made differently and each offers its own advantages.
Understanding how they’re built can help you choose the decking material that’s right for your home, lifestyle, and budget.
Composite Decking
Composite decking is made from a blend of recycled wood fibers and recycled plastics, protected by a durable outer cap. It delivers the warm appearance of wood while greatly reducing maintenance compared to traditional lumber.
Composite decking is durable, attractive, and offers outstanding value for homeowners looking to build a beautiful deck without moving into the premium price category.
The two composite deck lines we recommend the most are Trex Enhance Naturals and TimberTech Prime+.
Advanced PVC Decking
Advanced PVC decking is manufactured without wood fibers.That may sound like a small difference, but it changes how the material performs.
Wood naturally absorbs and releases moisture as weather conditions change. By eliminating wood fibers from the board, Advanced PVC decking is engineered for exceptional moisture resistance, making it especially well suited for Minnesota’s rain, snow, humidity, and freeze-thaw cycles.
Advanced PVC is also known for its premium appearance, realistic wood grain, and rich color blending, making it a favorite among homeowners looking to create a truly high-end outdoor living space.
What does fully capped mean?
A fully capped board has a protective outer layer that wraps around the entire board—not just the top. This helps protect against moisture, stains, scratches, and UV exposure, so your deck stays beautiful with minimal maintenance. The two Advanced PVC collections we recommend most often—TimberTech Harvest® and TimberTech Vintage®—are fully capped.
Budget, Good, Better, Best Recommendations
Now, let's jump right into it! As a reminder, we’ve grouped our four most recommended decking collections into a simple framework to make comparing your options easier.
Budget: Trex® Enhance Naturals
Good: TimberTech® Prime+
Better: TimberTech® Harvest
Best: TimberTech® Vintage
Budget: Trex Enhance Naturals
Trex Enhance Naturals is an excellent entry point into low-maintenance decking. It offers homeowners a durable, attractive deck at an approachable price, making it a great choice for replacing an aging wood deck or maximizing value without sacrificing quality.
Why Homeowners Choose Trex® Enhance Naturals
Affordable entry into composite decking
Low-maintenance ownership
Beautiful wood-inspired colors
Made with recycled materials
Backed by a 25-Year Limited Residential Warranty and 25-Year Limited Fade & Stain Warranty
Things to Consider
Trex Enhance Naturals is designed around value. Compared to our premium collections, it offers simpler wood grain patterns, less color variation, and a shorter warranty.
Like many composite decking products, Trex Enhance Naturals features a three-sided protective cap, covering the top and both sides of the board while leaving the bottom uncapped. This design provides excellent everyday protection while helping keep the product affordable.
Good: TimberTech® Prime+
For homeowners looking to elevate the appearance of their deck without leaving the composite category, TimberTech Prime+ is a noticeable step up.
Prime+ builds on the benefits of composite decking with richer color blending, more defined wood grain, and a more refined finish. The result is a deck that feels more custom and complements today’s outdoor living spaces.
Why Homeowners Choose TimberTech® Prime+
Richer, more realistic wood grain
Enhanced color depth
Clean installation with hidden fastener compatibility
Low-maintenance ownership
Backed by a 30-Year Limited Product Warranty and 30-Year Limited Fade & Stain Warranty
Things to Consider
Like Trex Enhance Naturals, Prime+ is a three-sided capped composite board, with protective capping on the top and sides while the bottom remains uncapped.
Three-Sided vs. Fully Capped Construction
Trex® Enhance Naturals and TimberTech® Prime+ feature a three-sided protective cap, covering the top and sides of each board. This durable cap helps protect against everyday wear.
TimberTech® Harvest and Vintage take protection a step further with a fully capped design that wraps around the entire board—including the bottom. This provides complete protection around the board, offering enhanced defense against moisture, stains, scratches, and UV exposure.
Better: TimberTech Harvest
If you’re looking for the best balance of beauty, performance, and long-term value, TimberTech® Harvest is the collection we recommend most often.
Harvest is where many homeowners realize the upgrade is worth it. Manufactured with TimberTech’s Advanced PVC technology, it combines exceptional moisture resistance with a timeless painted wood appearance that’s equally at home on a modern home, a lake cabin, or a traditional neighborhood deck.
Why Homeowners Choose Harvest
Advanced PVC construction with no wood fibers
Fully capped for complete protection around the entire board
Beautiful painted wood appearance with timeless color options
Exceptional resistance to moisture
No sanding, staining, or sealing
Limited Lifetime Product Warranty
50-Year Limited Fade & Stain Warranty
Why We Recommend It
Harvest delivers what many homeowners are looking for: premium performance without stepping into TimberTech’s highest-end collection.
For many of our customers, it represents the “sweet spot” in the lineup. Offering a noticeable upgrade in material technology, appearance, and warranty coverage while remaining a practical long-term investment.
Best: TimberTech® Vintage
For homeowners who want the very best, TimberTech Vintage® is the pinnacle of our decking lineup.
Built with the same Advanced PVC technology as Harvest, Vintage takes aesthetics to the next level with richer color blending, deeper texture, and a remarkably realistic hardwood appearance.
It’s designed for homeowners who want every detail of their outdoor living space to feel exceptional.
Why Homeowners Choose Vintage
Premium Advanced PVC construction with no wood fibers
Fully capped for complete protection around the entire board
TimberTech’s most realistic wood-inspired appearance
Rich multi-tonal color blending
Premium texture and finish
Minimal maintenance
Limited Lifetime Product Warranty
50-Year Limited Fade & Stain Warranty
Weatherguard Insight
The biggest difference between Harvest and Vintage isn’t durability—they’re both built with TimberTech’s Advanced PVC technology, feature fully capped construction, and include the same Limited Lifetime Product Warranty and 50-Year Limited Fade & Stain Warranty. The decision comes down to appearance.
Still Not Sure Which Decking Collection Is Right for You?
The best way to choose decking is to experience it in person.
Schedule a free deck design consultation to explore full-size samples of Trex® Enhance Naturals, TimberTech® Prime+, TimberTech® Harvest, TimberTech® Vintage, and any other decking collections you’d like to compare. We’ll walk you through the differences in materials, colors, textures, warranties, and performance, answer your questions, and help you confidently choose the decking that’s the best fit for your home and the way you plan to enjoy your outdoor living space.
Ready to start planning your dream deck? Contact Weatherguard today to schedule your free consultation.
